Is Medication the Only Solution for Depression or Anxiety?
Often, when an individual comes into their physician’s office with depression and/or anxiety they are prescribed medication. Present medications used to help patients may include Effexor, Celexa and Ceprolex. In my opinion, after 35 years of clinical practice, such medications can be of great importance and may even prevent self-harming behaviours. I and my colleagues have also recommended that clients speak with their physician about mediations to support them during therapy.
However, there has been research in the 2010 Journal of the Medical Association that anti-depressant meds are not shown to be more effective than placebos except in those individuals with severe depression symptoms. Harvard Medical School corroborated similar results in 2014.
There are many studies that indicate that psychotherapy is as, or is more effective than anti-depressant medications. As a therapist and a clinical director for more than 30 years, I can state that many clients will benefit from counselling therapy – but why?
- Effective therapy can support clients become more resilient.
- Therapy can support a client to raise their level of independence and even their functioning
- It focuses on building support systems – with family or friends and relationships – and prevents isolation
- Therapy helps clients move through the complexities of the emotional system and teaches how they can soothe that reactive system that sometimes becomes a liability – especially in stressful situations with others or their environments.
- Therapy is a hopeful process; optimism is a necessary part of the therapist’s belief that change is possible
- Therapy is a collaboration between the therapist and the client that can yield change and healing.
- Therapy can be short or long term; change can occur in either, though it is thought that long-term change comes from a longer commitment to the therapy process.
There is unquestionably the need for medication for some people but not all people experiencing difficulties such as depression and anxiety. Individuals experiencing symptoms should always seek medical attention promptly and explore options for medications, if indicated.
Psychotherapy can also play a significant role by promoting mental health and effecting positive long-term changes.
In good health,
MSc. PCFTTA, RPC
Clinical Director, West Coast Wellness Group
Jewish Family Services